Checklist
Does your project require ethical approval?
Read the guidance and download the checklist to determine whether your project requires ethical approval and to find the appropriate ethical process for your project.
Updated on 16 November 2026
If you are a member of staff or a student at the university who plans to collect or analyse data from or about human beings, or access security-sensitive material as a requirement of your role at the university, then you need to consider what ethical approvals your project may need. UREC have developed a checklist which you can download below to help you to find the appropriate ethical process for your project.
A key step in determining whether your project requires university ethical approval is to determine whether it is or is not research as defined by the University.
i) Definition of research
The key source of reference for determining whether an activity is or is not research is the Frascati Manual. The University is required to use the Frascati definition of research and development to report income from externally funded research to the UK Higher Education Statistical Agency (HESA) and to record research activity for the Transparent Approach to Costing (TRAC) methodology, which determines indirect cost rates for grant applications.
The Frascati definition of research and development is summarised in the extracts below:
“Research and experimental development (R&D) comprise creative and systematic work undertaken in order to increase the stock of knowledge - including knowledge of humankind, culture and society - and to devise new applications of available knowledge.”
“The term R&D covers three types of activity: basic research, applied research and experimental development. Basic research is experimental or theoretical work undertaken primarily to acquire new knowledge of the underlying foundations of phenomena and observable facts, without any particular application or use in view. Applied research is original investigation undertaken in order to acquire new knowledge. It is, however, directed primarily towards a specific practical aim or objective. Experimental development is systematic work, drawing on knowledge gained from research, practical experience, and producing additional knowledge, which is directed to producing new products or processes or to improving existing products or processes.”
The creation/acquisition of new knowledge and uncertainty about the final outcome are key elements of the definition. Further details can be found in chapter 2 of the Frascati Manual.
The Health Research Authority (HRA) has produced a leaflet (Defining Research) to help healthcare researchers differentiate between research, clinical audit, service evaluation, public health surveillance and usual practice. The Medical Research Council (MRC) and HRA have developed an online decision tool, 'Is my study research', based on this leaflet to help researchers determine whether their project would be considered research as defined by the UK Policy Framework for Health and Social Care Research. A second decision tool, ‘Do I need NHS REC approval?’, has been developed to help researchers determine whether their research requires approval by an NHS REC. Further advice can be obtained from TASC ([email protected]).
However, note that health and social care research involving human participants that does not require NHS REC approval but is in or through the NHS (e.g research involving NHS staff as participants) will still require UREC approval if it meets the Frascati definition of research.
ii) Activities not requiring ethical approval
Activities that do not meet the Frascati definition of research will not require ethical approval. These include:
- Performance reviews
- Testing within normal education requirements
- Literary or artistic criticism
- Quality Assurance studies/Audits of standard practice (not involving identifiable records) – designed to find out whether a service meets pre-determined standards. Examples include assessment of teaching practices and clinical audit
- Service Evaluation – designed solely (i.e. not as part of a research project) to assess what standard the service achieves
- Public Health Surveillance
Clinical audit and service evaluation projects must be registered with the appropriate Board/Trust; please contact TASC ([email protected]) for advice on how and where to register such projects. If you do not usually have access to the required patient data (patient-identifiable information) you should apply for Caldicott Guardian approval through NHST or the appropriate Board/Trust to access the data. Please contact TASC for further information and advice ([email protected]).
iii) Research led by other UK HEIs
In line with UKRI research council guidance, UREC seek to avoid the unnecessary duplication of ethical review. Research conducted within UK HEI institutions is bound to the same ethical and legal context, and the primary responsibility for ethical review lies with the host institution of the principal investigator. However, in cases where University of Dundee researchers are involved in research being led by collaborators at other UK institutions, it is due diligence to confirm and store a record of ethical approval.
Before receiving data or contributing to authorship of a project based at another UK HEI, researchers should request a copy of the ethical approval letter and submit this to their UoD SREC for logging. This ensures an ethical audit trail for all UoD affiliated research. Note, in advance of any data processing you must also ensure that the proposed research complies with the University of Dundee’s legislative and regulatory obligations in respect of data protection, further information on data sharing can be found on the Standard data sharing/processing agreements web page.
iv) Research conducted overseas
Research conducted outwith the UK should follow the University Guidance for approval of international research projects.
Healthcare research conducted overseas cannot be reviewed by an NHS REC and should follow the University research ethics process as described in this guidance. Approvals from the host country and the university must then be shared with Tayside Medical Science Centre (TASC) Research Governance ([email protected]) for confirmation of sponsorship. Projects must not start before sponsorship is confirmed.
Guardian approval through NHST or the appropriate Board/Trust to access the data. Please contact TASC for further information and advice ([email protected]).
v) Secondary Data Analysis
In the case of anonymised datasets which have been curated and made publicly available to researchers for the purposes of open science, consent for use by other researchers should be a precondition of publication. Although you should act in ethically (including crediting the original source) when working with these data, formal university ethical approval is not normally required unless needed for access, publication or student learning.
In the case of data that are publicly available but have not been explicitly consented for use in research (e.g. data shared in online forums); data that are potentially identifiable (either through qualitative content or combination of sources); data which are security sensitive; and/or data shared in contexts where consent for reuse is unclear, you should consult the university research ethics webpages for relevant guidance (e.g. guidance for internet mediated research) and submit your application for university review.
In the case of data which is unpublished but privately available (e.g. generated by a previous research project), data can only be made available to other researchers for analysis when this reuse has been explicitly consented, and you should provide evidence of this when seeking ethical approval for the project.
vi) What if I'm not sure?
If you are unsure whether or not your project falls within the definition of research or requires formal ethical approval after completing the checklist, please contact UREC for advice.
Downloads
- Type
- Download