Press release

Distrust of management grows among senior hospital doctors

Doctors’ distrust of their employers spiked in the aftermath of the Covid-19 pandemic, with many senior hospital doctors in Scotland expressing an intention to retire early, scale down work commitments, or leave the NHS as a result.

Published on 17 November 2026

An exterior shot of the School of Business building at dusk

Graham Martin

These views were expressed in a new study incorporating projects led by the University of Dundee in conjunction with NEOMA Business School in France and Edinburgh Napier University. The research, published in the prestigious Journal of Management Studies, analysed responses from three surveys of senior hospital doctors in Scotland conducted during an eight-year period – in 2015, 2020 and 2023.

In 2015, many doctors expressed limited confidence in senior leadership. They described bureaucracy, loss of professional autonomy, workforce pressures and a perceived gap between managerial priorities and clinical realities. However, most acknowledged difficult constraints facing managers while retaining hope that relationships could improve.

The 2020 survey took place during the first phase of the pandemic, when doctors reported increased feelings of being trusted to solve problems and believed that managers were listening to clinical judgement. This produced a temporary state of high trust and low distrust in their organisations.

However, respondents believed that these positive changes were not sustained, with 2023 accounts describing an increased loss of autonomy, feeling devalued, bullying or disrespectful management, and organisational priorities perceived as conflicting with patient care. 

Doctors increasingly expressed negative expectations about what their employer or its leaders would do in future. Their comments were characterised by cynicism, disillusionment, anger, and an increasing desire to retire early or scale down work commitments to the NHS. Clinicians expected future decisions to be unfair, harmful or inconsistent with professional values.

Professor Graeme Martin, Chair of Management at Dundee, said that the findings can be explained by raised expectations during the early pandemic period being subsequently dashed. 

“Many doctors believed that greater autonomy, collaboration and clinical influence could be continued following the early stages of the pandemic,” he said. “These expectations effectively became part of an unwritten ‘psychological’ contract between doctors and their employing organisations.

“Distrust is evident when employees confidently hold negative expectations of their employers’ intentions and behaviours. It does not always develop through a steady accumulation of negative experiences. It can become particularly strong when a period of improvement raises clinicians’ expectations, but the promised or anticipated changes are subsequently unmet.

“The early response to Covid-19 temporarily improved trust. Doctors reported greater professional autonomy and status, faster clinically led decision-making, better collaboration and more visible support from leaders. Many interpreted these changes as evidence that a more respectful and clinically informed relationship with the organisation was possible.  

“However, when healthcare organisations later returned to ‘business as usual’, these renewed expectations were unfulfilled. Many saw it as a betrayal of professional values and of an implicit promise about how they would be treated in the future. Trust therefore declined while active distrust, including scepticism, cynicism and expectations of future harm, increased.”

The paper concludes with important lessons for healthcare managers, noting that the early pandemic period showed the value of rapid decision-making, clinical leadership, local autonomy and cross-professional collaboration.  It warns that “health boards should identify which of these practices can be sustained and explain openly why others cannot”.

Respondents provided 430 lengthy free-text responses to the 2015 survey, 220 in 2020 and 1530 in 2023. The surveys covered all 14 regional health boards in NHS Scotland in 2015 and 2023. Because of the restrictions on research during the pandemic, the 2020 survey only covered one large regional board which was previously found to be typical of other boards.

Professor Martin’s co-authors on the paper are Dr Branko Bozic, Associate Professor at NEOMA Business School, and Dr Stacey Bushfield, Associate Professor at Edinburgh Napier University Business School.

Enquiries

Grant Hill

Senior Public Affairs Officer

+44 (0)1382 384768

[email protected]
Story category Research