University Logo University of Dundee Tay Bridge Picture

TCGP Image

Asthma Research Unit Posters

Tayside Centre for General PracticeAsthma Research Unit
Research Button
Staff Button
Publications Button
Links Button



Medinex Link

 

Social Deprivation, Childhood Asthma
and Health Service Utilisation

Presented at the BTS Conference
9th December 1996 in London

Mowat D, McCowan C, Neville R G, Warner F C,
Crombie I K, Clark R A and Ricketts I W


Introduction

The relationship between socio-economic status and asthma is not clearly defined. A recent review paper [Mielck A, Reitmeir P, Wjst M. Severity of childhood asthma by socio-economic status. Int J Epid 1996 25 No 2 388-393] noted that while a number of studies had found a link between asthma and low-socio economic status an equal number of studies did not find any such relationship. The aims of this study were to assess if socio-economic status influences the severity of asthma and whether children from different social backgrounds utilise Health Services in the same manner.

Method

A group of 1504 children aged 1-15, with asthma or asthma like symptoms, identified from a previous study [Bryce FP et al Controlled trial audit. BMJ 1995 310 838-844] received standard medical care for asthma over a 4 year period. An index of deprivation based on 1991 census data was assigned to each child by home postcode. The identified cohort were divided into quartiles based on this index of deprivation. Group 1 contained the children from the most affluent background and deprivation increased to Group 4 which represented the children with the lowest socio-economic status. Severity of asthma was classified by BTS Treatment Steps and the patterns of care in general practice and the hospital setting were also examined.

Results

The data shows no influence of socio-economic status on BTS treatment step to which individual children were assigned (Table 1). Children in the affluent social groups attended their GPs more often for routine review of their asthma, although patient initiated consultations were similar for all groups. Socially deprived children had a higher rate of attendance at hospital outpatient clinics and were admitted to hospital more often than their prosperous contemporaries. (Table 2)

                                  BTS Step by Deprivation Group - Year 4

 

Care Contacts for Asthma over 4 Years

   

Primary

Secondary

Deprivation Quartile

BTS

Step 0

BTS

Step 1

BTS

Step 2

BTS

Step 3

BTS

Step 4

 

Asthma

Consultation

GP/Nurse

Review

Hospital

Admission

Out Patient

Clinic

Group 1

243(64.6)

52(13.8)

6(1.6)

29(7.7)

46(12.2)

 

745

725

23

199

Group 2

254(67.6)

46(12.2)

8(2.1)

3(8.5)

36(9.6)

 

804

701

22

100

Group 3

242(63.9)

44(11.6)

9(2.4)

31(8.2)

53(14.0)

 

939

557

27

251

Group 4

260(69.7)

38(10.2)

2(0.5)

29(7.8)

44(11.8)

 

743

487

52

216

Conclusion

Severity of asthma as classified by BTS treatment Steps does not appear to be related to socio-economic status for this identified cohort. However socio-economic status appears to influence patterns of Health Service utilisation. Children with adverse social circumstances receive less preventative follow up care in general practice and a consequence of this may be more hospital admissions and outpatient attendances.

 



For further information on the Asthma Research Unit, please contact:
Tayside Centre for General Practice
University of Dundee
Kirsty Semple Way
Dundee DD2 4BF
Scotland
Tel : +44 (0)1382 420000
Fax :+44 (0)1382 420010

aru@tcgp.dundee.ac.uk

Updated by Mark Stewart: Tuesday, November 6, 2001