University Logo University of Dundee Tay Bridge Picture

TCGP Image

Asthma Research Unit Past & Present Projects

Tayside Centre for General PracticeAsthma Research Unit
Research Button
Staff Button
Publications Button
Links Button



Medinex Link


All the projects are based at the Tayside Centre for General Practice. A list of publications and reprint ordering information can be found on the publications page.

Past & Present Research Projects

Projects presently undertaken by the Unit include :
  1. A Qualitative Investigation of treatment Goals,
    Asthma Severity and Deprivation
  2. Scottish Asthma Management Initiative (SAMI)-
    Final Executive Summary - PDF and Word documents available
  3. General Practitioners in Asthma Group Internet Service
  4. Web builder
  5. Asthma Patient Review - Tayside Asthma Software
  6. Asthma Attacks at A&E

    new
  7. E-MAIL CONSULTATIONS IN GENERAL PRACTICE
    * Full Research Paper - PDF document
    * Project Report - PDF document

Previous projects 

  1. Computerised Decision Support for Asthma in General Practice
  2. Identifying Patients at Risk of an Asthma Exacerbation
  3. Clinician-Led WWW Respiratory Site
  4. National Audit of Acute Asthma Attacks
  5. Tayside Childhood Asthma Project
  6. National Asthma Management Study
  7. Asthma and Growth in Tayside Children
  8. Economic Evaluation of Acute Asthma Attack

Current Projects

1. A Qualitative Investigation of treatment goals.   Asthma Severity and Deprivation

This project has been funded by the NHS R&D to do a qualitative study of patient's treatment goals in asthma.  The study, based in the Asthma Group, will develop the knowledge of the patient's perspective of asthma treatments and outcomes.  This accords with the Asthma Group's previous work on enhancing health professional-patient communication and developing a partnership in care.  It is envisaged that in future studies patient goals will be incorporated in asthma management plans.
 
Research Poster
A Quantative Investigation of Treatment Goals and Asthma Severity - Presented at the National Asthma Conference, London, June 1999

Return to Top


2. Scottish Asthma Management Initiative (SAMI)

This Scottish Office initiative gives GPs in all regions of Scotland the chance to work with the Unit to improve the care of patients with asthma.  The initiative, piloted in Tayside and Fife, comprises a data recording booklet linked to an educational programme.  The interactive and personalised feedback aims to reduce patient morbidity, including hospital admissions.

Hoskins G, Smith B, Neville RG, Clark RA. The Tayside Asthma Management Initiative. Health Bulletin 56(2) March 1998

Initial SAMI Flyer

Information on the Study

Research Posters

1.  Frequency of Symptoms in Patients Attending for Asthma Assessment in UK General Practices
- Presented at ATS Conference, San Diego, Apr 99
.

2.  Asthma Management Initiative in Scotland
- Presented at ATS Conference, San Diego, Apr 99
.

3.  The effect of a trained asthma nurse on patient outcomes in general practice
- Presented at the GPIAG Conference Oxford, Jun 98


4.  Structure, Process and Outcome of Asthma Clinics.
- Presented at CRAG Conference, Edinburgh, Dec 97

Return to Top


3. General Practitioners in Asthma Group Internet Service

The unit has ties with the WWW site for the GPIAG, a group of UK wide GPs who share a common interest in asthma. We also provide Internet access to all GPIAG members allowing them to surf the web and send and receive e-mail. This project is funded by Allen & Hanburys Ltd.

Ricketts IW, McCowan C, Neville RG, Warner FC, Cairns AY, Cobley AC. Connecting the GPIAG - One years experience. Mednet 97 1997 ISSN 1350-3162 PS10 42

Research Posters

1.  Connecting the GPIAG One Year's Experience
- Presented at the MEDNET 97 Conference held in Brighton, Nov 97

2.  GPIAG Internet Service - Two years On
- Presented at the NAC Conference London, Feb 98

3.  What Methods of Communication Do GPs Prefer to Use
- Presented at the GPIAG Conference Oxford, Jun 98

Return to Top


4. Web Builder

User friendly software is being developed as part of a project involving Tayside Health Board (FINIX), Tayside Centre for General Practice and the Department of Applied Computing.  This sofware will use an easy-to-use data-entry interface to capture the information from each Practice and will generate complete web sites from the information that the practices provide.

'Interested' click for more information

Research Poster

"Web Doctor" - WWWeb Page Designing Software for General Practices.
- Presented at BCS Medical Scotland, Jun 98

Return to Top



7. E-MAIL CONSULTATIONS IN GENERAL PRACTICE
This project developed and evaluated an e-mail service enabling communication between patients and their general practice regarding repeat prescriptions, appointment booking and clinical enquiries. The service was developed in an urban practice within Dundee in early 2003 and evaluated after six months. There were 150 patients recruited to the service and satisfaction with the service was very high. Patients specifically commended the practice for setting up a facility to allow communication out with standard working hours and for the ease of ordering repeat prescriptions. Patients were pleased to have a means of seeking their doctor’s comment or opinion without bothering him or her by making and attending a formal face to face consultation.
 
* Full Research Paper - PDF document
* Project Report - PDF document

Return to Top

Past Projects

1. Computerised Decision Support for Asthma in General Practice
This project (funded by the Scottish Home and Health Dept., Scottish Office) produced a computer-based decision support program for use during asthma consultations in General Practice. Clinicians were issued with management advice related to current concensus treatment guidelines dependant on the consulting patient's circumstances.

The difficulties faced by the researchers included first developing a working program which was both easy to use but fast and accurate, and secondly the task of persuading GPs to use a computer to aid with consultations. Many people saw the medical consultation as one of the few areas computers had not penetrated and our task was to produce a project to persuade GPs that there was a place for the computer.

McCowan C, Neville RG, Cairns AY, Ricketts IW, Warner FC, Clark RA, Thomas GE. Computer-assisted assessment and management of patients with asthma - a preliminary report. Conference proceedings of Healthcare Computing 1997 Part 1 BJHC Limited, Surrey ISBN 0948198265 117-121.

Research Poster

Computer Assisted Assessment and Management of patients with Asthma.
-  Presented at the Healthcare Computing Conference, Harrogate, Mar 97.

Return to Top


2. Identifying Patients at Risk of an Asthma Exacerbation

Using an existing database of 12,203 patients this project, funded by Zeneca, aimed to identify the characteristics of patients who might benefit from a change in therapy and what the health economics of such a change might be. This database included details on health service utilisation, prescriptions, BTS guideline therapy 'steps', and symptoms on recent clinical assessment.

Research Posters:

1.  Identifying Patients "At Risks" of an Exacerbation of Asthma.   G Hoskins, C McCowan, G E Thomas, R G Neville, B Smith, S Silverman - Presented at the European Respiratory Society Conference Geneva, Sep 98.

2.  Asthma in the Elderly - Are We Getting it Right?
G Hoskins, C McCowan, G E Thomas, B Smith, R G Neville and R A Clark - Presented at the World Asthma Conference Barcelona, Dec 98.

3.  Symptoms, Treatment Step and Admission Rates in 12,203 UK Asthmatics.   Neville R G, McCowan C, Hoskins G, Thomas G E - Presented at the World Asthma Conference Barcelona, Dec 98.

4.  The Economic Implications of an Asthma Attack.  G Hoskins, B Smith, C Thomson, M Sculpher, C McCowan and R G Neville - Presented at the European Respiratory Society Conference Berlin, Sep 97.

5.  Counting the Costs of Poorly Controlled Asthma in the Community.  G Hoskins, C McCowan, R G Neville, B Smith, G E Thomas, S Silverman.  Presented at the American Thoracic Society Conference San Diego, Apr 99.

6.  Assessing the Management  and Associated Costs of Paediatric Asthma in the Community.  National Asthma Campaign Conference London, Jun 99.  G Hoskins, C McCowan, R G Neville, B Smith, G E Thomas, S Silverman.

Return to Top


3.  Clinician-led WWW Respiratory Site

A Scottish Office funded two year project the aims of which were: to provide a novel service giving GPs in Scotland desktop access to computerised decision support software for the management of asthma; to establish a methodology for the development of internet based add-ons for GPASS and other general practice or hospital computer systems; to promote the use of the SIGN guidelines for Asthma in general practice.  The project was a good example of research theory being used in practice; the respiratory WWW site would become a focus for disseminating information by Scottish Office, GPASS and other groups.

Why not visit the new site: http://www.srs.org.uk/

Return to Top


4. National Audit of Acute Asthma Attacks

In 1991/92 218 general practitioners participated in a postal survey recording details of 1,805 patients who had suffered an asthma attack within a specific three month period. This UK wide survey of the management of asthma attacks within general practice, funded by the GP's in Asthma Group, highlighted the gap between recommended and actual management. The underuse of systemic steroids and nebulised bronchodilators in attacks of all degrees of severity was of particular concern. With the publication of revised guidelines in 1993 there was an opportunity to repeat the audit and assess any change in line with guidelines. For the second survey 299 GPs recorded details of 2,332 patients. Although an improvement was recorded with more use of systemic steroids being used and step up in preventative therapy more practised, it still fell short of recommended management. Work to encourage best possible practice continues.

Neville RG, Clark RA, Hoskins G, Smith B for General Practitioners in Asthma Group. National Asthma Attack Audit 1991-92. BMJ 1993 306 559-62
Neville RG, Hoskins G, Smith B, Clark RA. How General Practitioners Manage Acute Asthma Attacks. Thorax 1997 52: (2) 153-156

Return to Top


5. Tayside Childhood Asthma Project

A controlled trial of an audit facilitator working with 12 General Practices showed that the care of children with asthma could be improved through the use of a predefined protocol for asthma care. Children with asthma or suspected asthma were identified to the practice and were given an asthma review. Medical records were reviewed on four occasions and data relating to their asthma and its treatment were recorded.

Bryce F P, Neville R G, Crombie I K, Clark R A, McKenzie P. Controlled trial of an audit facilitator in diagnosis and treatment of childhood asthma in general practice. BMJ 1995 310 838-42

McCowan C, Neville R G, Crombie I K, Clark R A, Warner F C. The facilitator effect : results from a 4-year follow-up of children with asthma. Br J GP 1997 47 156-160

Research Poster

1.  Social Deprivation, Childhood Asthma and Health Service Utilisation
- Presented at BTS London, Dec 96

2.  Asthma and Growth - the links between treatment, health service utilisation and social deprivation
- Presented at GPIAG Oxford, Jun 98

Return to Top


6. National

Asthma Management Study

General practices from throughout the UK were recruited to this study which was funded by Allen & Hanbury's Ltd. Participating practices reported on 30 randomly selected patients with asthma and these reports were auditted by the Research Unit. Each patient received an individual set of management recommendations, based on concensus guidelines, and the management of asthma in each practice was also positively criticised. This process was carried out for over 400 practices over a two-year period. The information collected formed the basis of a unique database on the management of asthma throughout the UK.

Neville RG, Hoskins G, Smith B, Clark RA. Observations on the structure, process and clinical outcomes of asthma care in general practice. Br J GP 1996 46 583-587.

Research Posters

1.  Observations on the structure, process and clinical outcomes of asthma care in general practice
- Presented at BTS Conference Dec 96

Return to Top


7. Asthma and Growth in Tayside Children

This project combined data from the Tayside Childhood Asthma Project and the Tayside Growth Study (TGS) to investigate the effect of asthma and its treatment on growth. The study followed over 3,000 children for a period of four years detailing asthma management and linking growth measurements taken by TGS. The aims of the study were to discover if asthma effected growth, if so was the disease or the treatment and how important was this impairment. The project was funded by the National Asthma Campaign .

The findings of the project indicate that there is a small sub-group of children with asthma who suffer from growth impairment. This is on average 6cm in a 14-year old boy. Clinicians have the difficult decision of whether to control asthma at the cost of growth or trying to find a balance, keeping the child free from excessive effects of their asthma but still allowing optimum growth.

Neville RG, McCowan C, Crombie IK, Thomas GE. Asthma and Growth - Cause for concern? Ann Hum Biol 1996 23 323-33

Return to Top


8. Economic Evaluation of Acute Asthma Attacks

This study highlights the cost to the health care service of treating patients who have suffered an exacerbation of asthma. Patient populations susceptible to exacerbations were identified from an existing database of 2,275 patients from throughout the United Kingdom. Published unit costs were applied to value resource use for each individual patient and the cost to the health service was then calculated.
By investigating the treatment costs in patients who experienced an asthma attack within a specified time period it was possible to quantify costs of differing patterns of care and estimate the health service cost of managing an asthma attack. Given the major cost burden to the health service it is possible that investment in increased use of preventative therapy in primary care could greatly reduce the economic burden on secondary care by reducing asthma instability. Further evaluation on outcomes over a longer period is required.

Hoskins G, Neville RG, Smith B, Clark RA. Economic implications of an asthma attack. Eur Res J 1997 10;(25)226s

Research Poster

Economic implications of an astma attack- Presented at the European Respiratory Society Berlin, Sep 97



For further information on the Asthma Research Unit, please contact:
Tayside Centre for General Practice
University of Dundee
Kirsty Semple Way
Dundee DD2 4BF
Scotland
Tel : +44 (0)1382 420000
Fax :+44 (0)1382 420010

aru@tcgp.dundee.ac.uk

Updated by Mark Stewart: Monday, June 14, 2004